300 US Highway 14
Arena, WI 53503
Phone: 608-753-2501
Fax: 608-753-2545
We are not responsible for shipping and weather delays. Refunds will not be granted for orders that are not delivered by your desired delivery date.
If you are shipping to any state that is warmer than 60 degrees during the day please go 2 Day air. California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado and Montana take longer than a week ground, your cheese will sit over the weekend.
We are only shipping on Monday and Tuesday's, unless it is a 2 day air order, we will ship on Wednesday.
Welcome To Arena Cheese!
Home of the Original Colby Jack Cheese, Cheese Curds and Holiday Gift Baskets!
Arena Cheese is located in the Wisconsin River Valley on State Highway 14 in Arena, Wisconsin. Arena Cheese is the home of the original Colby Jack Cheese and is easily recognized by the mouse in front of the cheese and gift store.
Arena Cheese is a 34-time medal winner in the US, World & ACS Cheese Contest!
Shop Online
Product Categories
12oz. Cheese Curds
A Wisconsin tradition, our cheese curds are taken directly from the cheese vat before it is pressed into solid form.
Brick Cheese
A mild to sweet flavor with a touch of nuttiness that becomes tangy and more pungent when aged. Available in Mild, Medium and Aged.
Cheddar Cheese
A traditional rich, buttery flavor available in various flavors aged from 1 to 10 years
Colby & Colby Jack Cheese
Our Specialty! A mild cheese similar to cheddar that is great for snacks and cooking sandwiches, and available in various flavors.
Gouda Cheese
A mild, nutty, creamy cheese with a pleasant (tangy) aroma. Available in Plain and Smoked Gouda.
Havarti Cheese
Creamy semi firm Danish style cheese. Havarti is a mild cheese with a distinct flavor. Also available in dill flavored.
Sausage
Award winning Jim's Sausage made in Wisconsin (Original, Beef or Garlic flavored) or Old Wisconsin Sausage.
Swiss Cheese
A mellow nutty buttery flavor with a firm texture & dime size holes. Typically made from part skim milk, we offer mild, medium & aged Swiss.
Recommended Items
Watch How Fresh Wisconsin Cheese is Made
Arena Cheese provides a viewing area so you can watch our artesian cheese maker making different varieties of cheeses, Monday - Friday. Samples of some of our various cheeses are available for your tasting pleasure. Don’t forget to take home fresh “squeaky” cheese curds made daily.
Bus tour groups are always welcome and a narrative of the cheese making process is available with an advance notice.
Below is a list of Arena Cheese's best selection of Wisconsin Cheese:
Natural Cheeses
Co-Jack
Colby
Chicken soup
Sriracha Jack
Pepper Jack
Pepper Jack Deli
Mild
Cheddar
Medium Cheddar
Sharp Cheddar
Super Sharp
Cheddar 2 yr
4yr Old Cheddar
Baby Swiss Full Cream
Pimento Colby
Medium Swiss
Aged Swiss
Mild Brick
Medium Brick
Aged Brick
Muenster
Caraway Muenster
Mozzarella Part Skim
Blue Cheese
Cream Havarti
Imported
Dill Havarti
Provolone
Smoked Provolone
Aged Provolone
Garlic Colby Jack
Fresh Cheese Curd 12 Oz.
Colby Caliente
6yr Old Cheddar
Party Pack
Vegetable Jack
Chipotle
Cheddar
Cranberry White Cheddar
10 yr Cheddar
Ghost
Pepper Cheddar
Tomato Basil Cheddar
Blueberry White
Cheddar
Monterey Jack
White Cheddar
Processed Cheese
Salami Cheese
Onion Cheese
Bacon Cheese
Smokey Swiss & Cheddar
Smoked Cheddar
Special Diet Cheeses
Lite Farmers
Miscellaneous
Goat cheese
honey/ plain
Gouda
Smoked Gouda
Chocolate Cheese
Limburger 8 oz.
String Cheese 16 oz
Smoked String Cheese
16 oz
String Cheese Whips 10 oz
Waxed Cheese 4oz.
Black & White Cow
Red Wisconsin Shape
Meats
Jim's 1# & 2# Summer Sausage
Old Wisc. 9oz
Summer Sausage
Old Wisc.
Beef Sticks
CHEESE SPREADS
Owls Nest Cheese
Spreads
Spicy Beer Spread
Kaukauna Lite Vegetable
Habanero
Please feel free to contact us or give us a call at 608-753-2501 for any questions or concerns.
Service Area: Arena, Madison, Sun Prairie, Monroe, Oregon, Verona, De Forest, Richland Center, Wisconsin Dells, Mc Farland, Mount Horeb, Cottage Grove and surrounding communities.
Page Summary: Order the best Wisconsin cheese curds, cheese gift baskets and Smoked Gouda online from Arena Cheese factory, makers of healthy Co-Jack Cheese, Gouda, brick cheese, Havarti, Aged Cheddar and others.
© 2015 - 2023 Arena Cheese, Inc., All rights reserved.
Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC