300 US Highway 14
Arena, WI 53503
Phone: 608-753-2501
Fax:  608-753-2545

0 Product(s) in cart |
Total $0.00 |
 Shopping cart

We only ship on Monday and Tuesday unless shipping 2 Day, we will ship on  Wednesday.  If the area is warm please use 2 Day and ice.  We will not refund any orders for warm cheese as we can't control shipping delays.

We are not responsible for shipping and weather delays. Refunds will not be granted for orders that are not delivered by your desired delivery date.  If you live in California, Texas, Florida, Arizona or Nevada please ship 2 day air.  Again, we will not refund product if it is warm.  

We currently make cheese and fresh curd on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday.  Store Hours Monday-Friday 8 AM - 5 PM, Saturday and Sunday 9 AM - 5 PM.

 

CATEGORIES


Cheddar Cheese

Home
» Cheddar Cheese
5 Year Cheddar Cheese
5 Year Cheddar Cheese
5 Year sharp Cheddar cheese.
Price$14.70
Apple Cinnamon Cheddar Cheese 1 lb.
Apple Cinnamon Cheddar Cheese 1 lb.
Try our Apple Cinnamon Cheddar Cheese. You will love it!
Price$13.50
Black and Green Olive Cheddar 1 lb.
Black and Green Olive Cheddar 1 lb.
Flavored with chunks of olives, our Black & Green Olive Cheddar Cheese features a traditional rich, buttery flavor and gets sharper with age.
Price$10.25
Blueberry Cheddar 1 lb.
Blueberry Cheddar 1 lb.
Our Blueberry Cheddar is a traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$10.25
Chipotle Cheddar 1 lb.
Chipotle Cheddar 1 lb.
Chipotle Cheddar is a white Cheddar cheese, infused with smokey chipolte flavor. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes sharper with age.
Price$9.45
Cranberry Cheddar 1 lb.
Cranberry Cheddar 1 lb.
Based on 2 ratings.
Our Cranberry Cheddar is a white Cheddar, with pieces of Cranberry. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$11.64
Fear the Reaper 0.5 lb.
Fear the Reaper 0.5 lb.
Spicy cheddar cheese with Carolina Reaper peppers. This is the hottest cheese we carry. 
Price$8.98
Ghost Pepper Cheddar 1 lb.
Ghost Pepper Cheddar 1 lb.
Our Ghost Pepper Cheddar is hot and spicy with pieces of ghost pepper. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$10.55
Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 1 lb.
Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 1 lb.
Cheddar cheese with bits of bacon and finished with a hickory smoke.
Price$10.95
Horseradish Cheddar 1 lb.
Horseradish Cheddar 1 lb.
Our Horseradish Cheddar is flavored with horseradish. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$10.75
Mango Fire 1 lb.
Mango Fire 1 lb.
Spicy cheese with mango and habanero peppers.
Price$14.25
Medium Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Medium Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Medium Cheddar Cheese offers a traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$6.20
Merlot Cheddar 1 lb.
Merlot Cheddar 1 lb.
Cheddar cheese with merlot wine.
Price$15.75
Mild Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Mild Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Mild Cheddar Cheese offers a traditional rich, buttery flavor that becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$5.90
Nut Brown Ale Cheddar Cheese
Nut Brown Ale Cheddar Cheese
White sharp Cheddar with Bull Falls Brewery Beer.
Price$13.10
Orange Cranberry Cheddar 1lb
Orange Cranberry Cheddar 1lb

Price$10.60
Portabella Mushroom and Chive Cheddar 1 lb.
Portabella Mushroom and Chive Cheddar 1 lb.
Cheddar Cheese with chunks of Portabella mushroom and chives.
Price$11.65
Rattle Snake 8 oz.
Rattle Snake 8 oz.
Spicy cheese with habanero peppers and tequila.
Price$8.00
« Previous12 »

Service Area: Arena, Madison, Middleton, Stoughton, Portage, Oregon, Platteville, Verona, Richland Center, Wisconsin Dells, Mc Farland, Mount Horeb and surrounding communities.

© 2015 - 2025 Arena Cheese, Inc., All rights reserved.

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC