CATEGORIES

All Cheese
12oz. Cheese Curds
Brick Cheese
Cheddar Cheese
Colby and Colby Jack Cheese
Cheese Gift Baskets
Gouda Cheese
Havarti Cheese
Other Items
Sausage
Swiss Cheese

All Cheese

Arena cheese has nearly 30 years of cheesemaking experience and understands that Arena's customers expect great, consistent and authentic cheeses. Arena Cheese's cheesemakers are eight-time medal winners in the U.S. and World Cheese Championships for Colby Longhorn and flavored semi-soft cheeses.

Home » All Cheese

Aged Brick Cheese 1 lb.

Aged Brick Cheese. A Wisconsin original. A mild to sweet flavor with a touch of nuttiness. Becomes tangy and more pungent when aged.

Price: $9.20

Aged Brick Cheese 1 lb.

Aged Brick Cheese. A Wisconsin original. A mild to sweet flavor with a touch of nuttiness. Becomes tangy and more pungent when aged.

Price: $9.20

Aged Provolone 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

The flavor changes from slightly pungent when young, to sharp when aged. It has a firm texture and becomes more granular when aged.

Price: $8.69

Aged Provolone 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

The flavor changes from slightly pungent when young, to sharp when aged. It has a firm texture and becomes more granular when aged.

Price: $8.69

Aged Swiss Cheese 1 lb.

A mellow nutty buttery flavor with a firm texture and dime size holes. Typically made from part skim milk, we offer, medium and aged Swiss

Price: $9.00

Aged Swiss Cheese 1 lb.

A mellow nutty buttery flavor with a firm texture and dime size holes. Typically made from part skim milk, we offer, medium and aged Swiss

Price: $9.00

Baby Swiss Cheese 1 lb.

A mild creamy nutty sweet flavor with smooth texture and smaller holes than traditional Swiss.

Price: $6.80

Baby Swiss Cheese 1 lb.

A mild creamy nutty sweet flavor with smooth texture and smaller holes than traditional Swiss.

Price: $6.80

Bellavitano Cheese 5.3 oz.

Come in different flavors; Espresso, Raspberry, Merlot, Chai, and gold.

Price: $5.40

Bellavitano Cheese 5.3 oz.

Come in different flavors; Espresso, Raspberry, Merlot, Chai, and gold.

Flavor

Price: $5.40

Black and Green Olive Cheddar 1 lb.

Flavored with chunks of olives, our Black & Green Olive Cheddar Cheese features a traditional rich, buttery flavor and gets sharper with age.

Price: $7.58

Black and Green Olive Cheddar 1 lb.

Flavored with chunks of olives, our Black & Green Olive Cheddar Cheese features a traditional rich, buttery flavor and gets sharper with age.

Price: $7.58

Blueberry Cheddar 1 lb.

Our Blueberry Cheddar is a traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

Price: $8.70

Blueberry Cheddar 1 lb.

Our Blueberry Cheddar is a traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

Price: $8.70

Buffalo Flavor Wisconsin Cheese Curds 12 oz.

Buffalo Flavor Wisconsin Cheese Curds, A Wisconsin tradition. Approximately 12 ounces of fresh cheese curds.

Price: $5.00

Buffalo Flavor Wisconsin Cheese Curds 12 oz.

Buffalo Flavor Wisconsin Cheese Curds, A Wisconsin tradition. Approximately 12 ounces of fresh cheese curds.

Price: $5.00

Chicken Soup Jack 1 lb.

This is a mix between Monterey jack and muenster mixed with Chicken soup mix.

Price: $9.30

Chicken Soup Jack 1 lb.

This is a mix between Monterey jack and muenster mixed with Chicken soup mix.

Price: $9.30

Chipotle Cheddar 1 lb.

Chipotle Cheddar is a white Cheddar cheese, infused with smokey chipolte flavor. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes sharper with age.

Price: $9.45

Chipotle Cheddar 1 lb.

Chipotle Cheddar is a white Cheddar cheese, infused with smokey chipolte flavor. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes sharper with age.

Price: $9.45

Chocolate Cheese 8 oz.

Creamy Havarti cheese with Coco.

Price: $9.75

Chocolate Cheese 8 oz.

Creamy Havarti cheese with Coco.

Price: $9.75

Chocolate Cheese with Cherries 8 oz.

Creamy Havarti cheese with coco and cherry chunks.

Price: $9.75

Chocolate Cheese with Cherries 8 oz.

Creamy Havarti cheese with coco and cherry chunks.

Price: $9.75

Out of Stock

Colby Caliente Cheese 1 lb.

Based on 2 ratings.

A traditional Colby cheese with jalapenos and chili powder blended in, to give it a hot and spicy flavor.

Price: $5.50

Colby Caliente Cheese 1 lb.

Based on 2 ratings.

A traditional Colby cheese with jalapenos and chili powder blended in, to give it a hot and spicy flavor.

Price: $5.50

Colby Cheese 1 lb.

A mild flavor cheese similar to cheddar. It has an open texture and is great for cooking sanwiches and snacks.

Price: $5.25

Colby Cheese 1 lb.

A mild flavor cheese similar to cheddar. It has an open texture and is great for cooking sanwiches and snacks.

Price: $5.25

Colby Deli Cheese 1 lb.

Same as colby only 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.

Price: $5.25

Colby Deli Cheese 1 lb.

Same as colby only 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.

Price: $5.25

Colby Jack Cheese 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

A delicate buttery flavor with a mixture of yellow and white color.

Price: $5.25

Colby Jack Cheese 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

A delicate buttery flavor with a mixture of yellow and white color.

Price: $5.25

Colby Jack Deli Cheese 1 lb.

Same as Colby Jack on 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.

Price: $5.25

Colby Jack Deli Cheese 1 lb.

Same as Colby Jack on 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.

Price: $5.25

Cranberry Cheddar 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

Our Cranberry Cheddar is a white Cheddar, with pieces of Cranberry. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

Price: $9.88

Cranberry Cheddar 1 lb.

Based on 1 ratings.

Our Cranberry Cheddar is a white Cheddar, with pieces of Cranberry. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.

Price: $9.88

« Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next »

All Cheese

Service Area: Arena, Madison, Stoughton, Baraboo, Monroe, Portage, Waunakee, Reedsburg, De Forest, Wisconsin Dells, Mc Farland, Cottage Grove and surrounding communities.