We are not responsible for shipping and weather delays.  Refunds will not be granted for orders that are not delivered by your desired delivery date.

If you are shipping to any states that are warmer than 70 degrees, choose overnight shipping.  We will not refund any product if you don't choose this method.  

We only ship ground on Monday's due to delayed shipping times.  If you are in need of your cheese sooner, please select overnight or 2 day.  


0 Product(s) in cart |
Total $0.00 |


All Cheese

Arena cheese has nearly 30 years of cheesemaking experience and understands that Arena's customers expect great, consistent and authentic cheeses. Arena Cheese's cheesemakers are eight-time medal winners in the U.S. and World Cheese Championships for Colby Longhorn and flavored semi-soft cheeses.

Cherry Wood Smoked Havarti 8 oz
Havarti Cheese that has been naturally smoked with cherry wood. 
Chicken Soup Jack 1 lb.
This is a mix between Monterey jack and muenster mixed with Chicken soup mix.
Chili Lime Havarti 8 oz
8 oz.creamy havarti cheese with a hint of chili lime. 
Chipotle Cheddar 1 lb.
Chipotle Cheddar is a white Cheddar cheese, infused with smokey chipolte flavor. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes sharper with age.
Chocolate Cheese 8 oz.
Creamy Havarti cheese with Coco.
Chocolate Cheese with Cherries 8 oz.
Creamy Havarti cheese with coco and cherry chunks.
Chocolate Cheese with Sea salt and Toffee 8oz.
Creamy Havarti cheese with bits of toffee and sea salt. 
Colby Caliente Cheese 1 lb.
A traditional Colby cheese with jalapenos and chili powder blended in, to give it a hot and spicy flavor.
Colby Cheese 1 lb.
A mild flavor cheese similar to cheddar. It has an open texture and is great for cooking sanwiches and snacks.
Colby Deli Cheese 1 lb.
Same as colby only 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.
Colby Jack Cheese 1 lb.
A delicate buttery flavor with a mixture of yellow and white color.
Colby Jack Deli Cheese 1 lb.
Same as Colby Jack on 4' round specifically made for a sandwich size slice.
Colby Swiss
Colby mixed with swiss cheese. 
Cranberry Cheddar 1 lb.
Our Cranberry Cheddar is a white Cheddar, with pieces of Cranberry. A traditional rich, buttery flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Dill Havarti 1 lb.
Creamy semi firm Danish style cheese. Havarti is a mild cheese with a distinct flavor.  This is flavored with Dill. 
Double Cream Brie
Creamy and buttery Brie. Sever with fresh fruit or a nice wine. 
Fear the Reaper 0.5 lb.
Spicy cheddar cheese with Carolina Reaper peppers. This is the hottest cheese we carry. 
Foraged Mushroom Jack 8 oz
Monterey Jack cheese blended with mushrooms and a hint of garlic.

Service Area: Arena, Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Monroe, Portage, Platteville, Verona, Reedsburg, Richland Center, Wisconsin Dells, Poynette and surrounding communities.

© 2015 - 2021 Arena Cheese, Inc., All rights reserved.

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC