300 US Highway 14
Arena, WI 53503
Phone: 608-753-2501
Fax:  608-753-2545

0 Product(s) in cart |
Total $0.00 |
 Shopping cart

All orders placed December 15th and before will ship before Christmas.  Any orders after December 15th must go 2nd Day Air.  

We only ship on Monday and Tuesday unless shipping 2 Day, we will ship on  Wednesday.  If the area is over 60 degrees please use 2 Day and ice.  We will not refund any orders for warm cheese as we can't control shipping delays.

We are not responsible for shipping and weather delays. Refunds will not be granted for orders that are not delivered by your desired delivery date.  If you live in California, Texas, Florida, Arizona or Nevada please ship 2 day air.  Again, we will not refund product if it is warm.  

We currently make cheese and fresh curd on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday.  Store Hours Monday-Friday 8 AM - 6 PM, Saturday and Sunday 9 AM - 6 PM.

 

CATEGORIES


Home
» All Products
Medium Swiss Cheese 16 oz
Medium Swiss Cheese 16 oz
A mellow nutty buttery flavor with a firm texture & dime size holes. Typically made from part skim milk, we offer mild, medium & aged Swiss.
Price$8.90
Merlot Cheddar 1 lb.
Merlot Cheddar 1 lb.
Cheddar cheese with merlot wine.
Price$15.75
Mild Brick Cheese 12 oz
Mild Brick Cheese 12 oz
Mild Brick Cheese. A Wisconsin original. A mild to sweet flavor with a touch of nuttiness. Becomes tangy and more pungent when aged.
Price$7.50
Mild Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Mild Cheddar Cheese - 1 lb.
Mild Cheddar Cheese offers a traditional rich, buttery flavor that becomes increasingly sharp with age.
Price$7.50
Mint Chocolate Cheese Fudge 8 oz
Mint Chocolate Cheese Fudge 8 oz
Rich creamy havarti cheese with added coco and mint. 
Price$8.60
Monterey Jack
Monterey Jack

Price$6.70
Morel and Leek Jack 6 oz
Morel and Leek Jack 6 oz
Monterey Jack cheese blended with mushrooms and a hint of garlic.
Price$6.25
Muenster Cheese 16 oz
Muenster Cheese 16 oz
A smooth classic texture that softens with age. It has an orange or white surface. The flavor changes from mild to mellow with age.
Price$7.50
Muscoda Mayhem 6 oz
Muscoda Mayhem 6 oz
Muscoda Mayhem is a spicy colby jack cheese.
Price$6.25
Old Wisconsin Sausage 8 oz.
Old Wisconsin Sausage 8 oz.
A Fine Wisconsin Sausage.
Price$6.35
Olives 16oz.
Olives 16oz.

Price$9.79
Onion Brick
Onion Brick
Mild brick cheese with onion and chives. 
Price$8.60
Orange Cranberry Cheddar 1lb
Orange Cranberry Cheddar 1lb

Price$12.75
Owl's Nest Cheese Spread 10 oz.
Owl's Nest Cheese Spread 10 oz.
Based on 3 ratings.
We don't produce Owl's Nest, we only sell it, currently having a hard time sourcing it.  We do update the site as soon as soon as it comes in with what is available.  The manufacturer did dis-continue the Horseradish.Owls Nest cheese spread comes in a 10oz container.
Price$6.25
Part Skim Mozzarella Cheese 1 lb.
Part Skim Mozzarella Cheese 1 lb.
A delicate milk flavor with a smooth and plastic texture. Melts and flows when heated.
Price$7.27
Pepper Jack
Pepper Jack
Monterey Jack cheese with jalapeno peppers.
Price$7.50
Pernats Beef Sticks 5 Pack
Pernats Beef Sticks 5 Pack
Comes in different flavors Hot (which is a regular beef), Hot Hot, Garlic, Garlic and Cheddar, Habanero, Bbq, Honey Bbq, Cheezy Sweet and Hot, Cracked Pepper, Pepperoni, Jalapeno Cheddar.
Price$9.99
Pimento Colby 1#
Pimento Colby 1#
Colby Cheese with Pimento peppers, Red Bells. It has an open texture & is great for cooking sanwiches & snacks.
Price$5.50
« 1234567 »

Service Area: Arena, Madison, Sun Prairie, Middleton, Monroe, Oregon, Verona, De Forest, Richland Center, Wisconsin Dells, Mc Farland, Dodgeville and surrounding communities.

© 2015 - 2025 Arena Cheese, Inc., All rights reserved.

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC